The Person You Fell For Never Existed

January 17, 2026

Have you ever dated someone and realized months later that you weren’t actually in love with them, you were in love with who you imagined they were? That gap between the person in your head and the person standing in front of you is what psychologist Carl Jung spent his career studying.

Here’s the simple version: We all walk around with an unconscious mental picture of our ideal partner. This picture gets built from movies, our parents, past relationships, and our own unmet needs. When we meet someone who seems to match that picture, we fill in the blanks with our imagination. We’re not seeing them. We’re seeing our fantasy projected onto them like a movie screen. Then when they act like themselves instead of our mental image, we feel betrayed even though they never promised to be that person in the first place.

A viral article recently framed this as something women do to men. But that’s not what Jung said. He said everyone does this. Men project onto women. Women project onto men. We all do it until we wake up to the pattern. The person who keeps dating “the wrong people” often isn’t unlucky, they’re repeatedly projecting the same fantasy onto different faces.

The way out isn’t building walls or becoming suspicious of partners. It’s getting honest with yourself about what you’re looking for and why. What qualities are you hoping a partner will provide that you haven’t developed in yourself? What fantasy are you carrying that no real human could fulfill? When you start asking those questions, you stop blaming others for failing to be your imaginary person and you start seeing the real human in front of you.

That’s it. No jargon needed. We fall for our projections, get disappointed by reality, and either blame the other person or finally look in the mirror.

0 Comments

Same Song, Different Ears

Same Song, Different Ears

Listen to Coldplay’s “Fix You” (or the version I prefer below the post) when you’re broken, and you hear a promise: someone will save me. Listen to it after...

The Weight of Seeing

The Weight of Seeing

We say the word so easily. Truth. We toss it around in conversations, claim to value it, insist we want it. But do we really understand what it means to hold...