Luigi and the Blind Spots of Judgment

December 11, 2024

The murder of UnitedHealthcare’s CEO has sparked widespread debate. On the surface, the case is straightforward: there’s motive, a weapon, and no doubt that Luigi killed. By the legal standard, the jury’s job is simple—examine the facts, convict.

But here’s the question we rarely ask: have we truly walked in Luigi’s shoes? Do we understand the daily, unrelenting pain of watching his mother suffer? Do we know if he had the resources or relationships to access the help he needed?

Social media thrives on quick conclusions. Assumptions about his wealth, his family, or his access to care flood timelines. But these assumptions miss the point: we all have blind spots. We project our limited experiences onto others, ignoring what we don’t—and can’t—understand about their reality.

This isn’t to justify killing. It’s to challenge the rush to judgment. The jurors face a unique dilemma: they must relate to Luigi’s humanity while setting aside emotion to uphold the law. But for the rest of us, the lesson is deeper.

Pause. Reflect. Consider. The chaos of recent years, from the pandemic to social upheaval, has forced us to confront how much we take for granted. Perhaps this case, too, is another moment to unsettle our assumptions and question what we’ve normalized.

Before we judge, let’s ask: are we seeing the world as it is—or only as we are?

0 Comments

The Fire Extinguisher Within

The Fire Extinguisher Within

We all know the fire extinguisher—encased in glass, hanging on a wall, waiting for a moment of crisis. We don’t think about it daily, but when a fire breaks...

The Cost of Not Asking Questions

The Cost of Not Asking Questions

I have been to Palestine. I traveled there with a non-violent activist group, whose goal was to create awareness of the situation there, for the average...

Step by Step, You’ll Get There

Step by Step, You’ll Get There

The darkest times feel unbearable. You hear the clichés—this too shall pass, one day at a time—and roll your eyes. But when you’re in it, when life knocks you...